Merge commit from fork

* fix(backend): Fix an issue where the origin of ActivityPub lookup response was not validated correctly.

[GHSA-6w2c-vf6f-xf26](https://github.com/misskey-dev/misskey/security/advisories/GHSA-6w2c-vf6f-xf26)

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

* Enhance: Add configuration option to disable all external redirects when responding to an ActivityPub lookup (config.disallowExternalApRedirect)

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

* fixup! fix(backend): Fix an issue where the origin of ActivityPub lookup response was not validated correctly.

* docs & one edge case

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

* apply suggestions

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

* remove stale frontend reference to _responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

* apply suggestions

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

---------

Signed-off-by: eternal-flame-AD <yume@yumechi.jp>

.config/cypress-devcontainer.yml

@@ -220,5 +220,10 @@ allowedPrivateNetworks: [
   '127.0.0.1/32'
 ]
 
+# Disable automatic redirect for ActivityPub object lookup. (default: false)
+# This is a strong defense against potential impersonation attacks if the viewer instance has inadequate validation.
+# However it will make it impossible for other instances to lookup third-party user and notes through your URL.
+#disallowExternalApRedirect: true
+
 # Upload or download file size limits (bytes)
 #maxFileSize: 262144000

.config/docker_example.yml

@@ -235,6 +235,11 @@ signToActivityPubGet: true
 #  '127.0.0.1/32'
 #]
 
+# Disable automatic redirect for ActivityPub object lookup. (default: false)
+# This is a strong defense against potential impersonation attacks if the viewer instance has inadequate validation.
+# However it will make it impossible for other instances to lookup third-party user and notes through your URL.
+#disallowExternalApRedirect: true
+
 # Upload or download file size limits (bytes)
 #maxFileSize: 262144000
 

.config/example.yml

@@ -334,6 +334,11 @@ signToActivityPubGet: true
 #  '127.0.0.1/32'
 #]
 
+# Disable automatic redirect for ActivityPub object lookup. (default: false)
+# This is a strong defense against potential impersonation attacks if the viewer instance has inadequate validation.
+# However it will make it impossible for other instances to lookup third-party user and notes through your URL.
+#disallowExternalApRedirect: true
+
 # Upload or download file size limits (bytes)
 #maxFileSize: 262144000
 

CHANGELOG.md

@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@
 - Fix: CWの注釈が100文字を超えている場合、ノート投稿ボタンを非アクティブに
 
 ### Server
+- Enhance: 成り済まし対策として、ActivityPub照会された時にリモートのリダイレクトを拒否できるように (config.disallowExternalApRedirect)
 - Fix: `following/invalidate`でフォロワーを解除しようとしているユーザーの情報を返すように
 - Fix: オブジェクトストレージの設定でPrefixを設定していなかった場合nullまたは空文字になる問題を修正
 - Fix: pgroongaでの検索時にはじめのキーワードのみが検索に使用される問題を修正  

locales/index.d.ts

@@ -10896,13 +10896,7 @@ export interface Locale extends ILocale {
              */
             "title": string;
             /**
-             * このサーバーと通信することはできましたが、得られたデータが不正なものでした。
+             * このサーバーと通信することはできましたが、得られたデータが不正なものでした。第三者のサーバーを介してリモートのコンテンツを照会している場合は、発信元のサーバーで取得できるURIを使用して照会し直してください。
-             */
-            "description": string;
-        };
-        "_responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch": {
-            /**
-             * 入力されたURIのドメインと最終的に得られたURIのドメインとが異なります。第三者のサーバーを介してリモートのコンテンツを照会している場合は、発信元のサーバーで取得できるURIを使用して照会し直してください。
              */
             "description": string;
         };

locales/ja-JP.yml

@@ -2911,9 +2911,7 @@ _remoteLookupErrors:
     description: "このサーバーとの通信に失敗しました。相手サーバーがダウンしている可能性があります。また、不正なURIや存在しないURIを入力していないか確認してください。"
   _responseInvalid:
     title: "レスポンスが不正です"
-    description: "このサーバーと通信することはできましたが、得られたデータが不正なものでした。"
+    description: "このサーバーと通信することはできましたが、得られたデータが不正なものでした。第三者のサーバーを介してリモートのコンテンツを照会している場合は、発信元のサーバーで取得できるURIを使用して照会し直してください。"
-  _responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch:
-    description: "入力されたURIのドメインと最終的に得られたURIのドメインとが異なります。第三者のサーバーを介してリモートのコンテンツを照会している場合は、発信元のサーバーで取得できるURIを使用して照会し直してください。"
   _noSuchObject:
     title: "見つかりません"
     description: "要求されたリソースは見つかりませんでした。URIをもう一度お確かめください。"

packages/backend/src/config.ts

@@ -73,6 +73,7 @@ type Source = {
 	proxyBypassHosts?: string[];
 
 	allowedPrivateNetworks?: string[];
+	disallowExternalApRedirect?: boolean;
 
 	maxFileSize?: number;
 
@@ -149,6 +150,7 @@ export type Config = {
 	proxySmtp: string | undefined;
 	proxyBypassHosts: string[] | undefined;
 	allowedPrivateNetworks: string[] | undefined;
+	disallowExternalApRedirect: boolean;
 	maxFileSize: number;
 	clusterLimit: number | undefined;
 	id: string;
@@ -287,6 +289,7 @@ export function loadConfig(): Config {
 		proxySmtp: config.proxySmtp,
 		proxyBypassHosts: config.proxyBypassHosts,
 		allowedPrivateNetworks: config.allowedPrivateNetworks,
+		disallowExternalApRedirect: config.disallowExternalApRedirect ?? false,
 		maxFileSize: config.maxFileSize ?? 262144000,
 		clusterLimit: config.clusterLimit,
 		outgoingAddress: config.outgoingAddress,

packages/backend/src/core/HttpRequestService.ts

@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ import type { Config } from '@/config.js';
 import { StatusError } from '@/misc/status-error.js';
 import { bindThis } from '@/decorators.js';
 import { validateContentTypeSetAsActivityPub } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/validator.js';
-import { assertActivityMatchesUrls } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
+import { assertActivityMatchesUrls, FetchAllowSoftFailMask } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
 import type { IObject } from '@/core/activitypub/type.js';
 import type { Response } from 'node-fetch';
 import type { URL } from 'node:url';
@@ -215,7 +215,7 @@ export class HttpRequestService {
 	}
 
 	@bindThis
-	public async getActivityJson(url: string, isLocalAddressAllowed = false): Promise<IObject> {
+	public async getActivityJson(url: string, isLocalAddressAllowed = false, allowSoftfail: FetchAllowSoftFailMask = FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict): Promise<IObject> {
 		const res = await this.send(url, {
 			method: 'GET',
 			headers: {
@@ -232,7 +232,7 @@ export class HttpRequestService {
 		const finalUrl = res.url; // redirects may have been involved
 		const activity = await res.json() as IObject;
 
-		assertActivityMatchesUrls(activity, [finalUrl]);
+		assertActivityMatchesUrls(url, activity, [finalUrl], allowSoftfail);
 
 		return activity;
 	}

packages/backend/src/core/activitypub/ApRequestService.ts

@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ import { LoggerService } from '@/core/LoggerService.js';
 import { bindThis } from '@/decorators.js';
 import type Logger from '@/logger.js';
 import { validateContentTypeSetAsActivityPub } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/validator.js';
-import { assertActivityMatchesUrls } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
+import { assertActivityMatchesUrls, FetchAllowSoftFailMask as FetchAllowSoftFailMask } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
 import type { IObject } from './type.js';
 
 type Request = {
@@ -185,7 +185,7 @@ export class ApRequestService {
 	 * @param url URL to fetch
 	 */
 	@bindThis
-	public async signedGet(url: string, user: { id: MiUser['id'] }, followAlternate?: boolean): Promise<unknown> {
+	public async signedGet(url: string, user: { id: MiUser['id'] }, allowSoftfail: FetchAllowSoftFailMask = FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict, followAlternate?: boolean): Promise<unknown> {
 		const _followAlternate = followAlternate ?? true;
 		const keypair = await this.userKeypairService.getUserKeypair(user.id);
 
@@ -243,7 +243,7 @@ export class ApRequestService {
 				if (alternate) {
 					const href = alternate.getAttribute('href');
 					if (href && this.utilityService.punyHost(url) === this.utilityService.punyHost(href)) {
-						return await this.signedGet(href, user, false);
+						return await this.signedGet(href, user, allowSoftfail, false);
 					}
 				}
 			} catch (e) {
@@ -258,7 +258,7 @@ export class ApRequestService {
 		const finalUrl = res.url; // redirects may have been involved
 		const activity = await res.json() as IObject;
 
-		assertActivityMatchesUrls(activity, [finalUrl]);
+		assertActivityMatchesUrls(url, activity, [finalUrl], allowSoftfail);
 
 		return activity;
 	}

packages/backend/src/core/activitypub/ApResolverService.ts

@@ -21,6 +21,7 @@ import { ApRendererService } from './ApRendererService.js';
 import { ApRequestService } from './ApRequestService.js';
 import type { IObject, ICollection, IOrderedCollection } from './type.js';
 import { IdentifiableError } from '@/misc/identifiable-error.js';
+import { FetchAllowSoftFailMask } from './misc/check-against-url.js';
 
 export class Resolver {
 	private history: Set<string>;
@@ -72,7 +73,7 @@ export class Resolver {
 	}
 
 	@bindThis
-	public async resolve(value: string | IObject): Promise<IObject> {
+	public async resolve(value: string | IObject, allowSoftfail: FetchAllowSoftFailMask = FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict): Promise<IObject> {
 		if (typeof value !== 'string') {
 			return value;
 		}
@@ -108,8 +109,8 @@ export class Resolver {
 		}
 
 		const object = (this.user
-			? await this.apRequestService.signedGet(value, this.user) as IObject
+			? await this.apRequestService.signedGet(value, this.user, allowSoftfail) as IObject
-			: await this.httpRequestService.getActivityJson(value)) as IObject;
+			: await this.httpRequestService.getActivityJson(value, undefined, allowSoftfail)) as IObject;
 
 		if (
 			Array.isArray(object['@context']) ?
@@ -119,18 +120,6 @@ export class Resolver {
 			throw new IdentifiableError('72180409-793c-4973-868e-5a118eb5519b', 'invalid response');
 		}
 		
-		// HttpRequestService / ApRequestService have already checked that
-		// `object.id` or `object.url` matches the URL used to fetch the
-		// object after redirects; here we double-check that no redirects
-		// bounced between hosts
-		if (object.id == null) {
-			throw new IdentifiableError('ad2dc287-75c1-44c4-839d-3d2e64576675', 'invalid AP object: missing id');
-		}
-
-		if (this.utilityService.punyHost(object.id) !== this.utilityService.punyHost(value)) {
-			throw new IdentifiableError('fd93c2fa-69a8-440f-880b-bf178e0ec877', `invalid AP object ${value}: id ${object.id} has different host`);
-		}
-
 		return object;
 	}
 

packages/backend/src/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.ts

@@ -4,18 +4,124 @@
  */
 import type { IObject } from '../type.js';
 
-export function assertActivityMatchesUrls(activity: IObject, urls: string[]) {
+export enum FetchAllowSoftFailMask {
-	const hosts = urls.map(it => new URL(it).host);
+	// Allow no softfail flags
+	Strict = 0,
+	// The values in tuple (requestUrl, finalUrl, objectId) are not all identical
+	//
+	// This condition is common for user-initiated lookups but should not be allowed in federation loop
+	//
+	// Allow variations:
+	//   good example: https://alice.example.com/@user -> https://alice.example.com/user/:userId
+	//   problematic example: https://alice.example.com/redirect?url=https://bad.example.com/ -> https://bad.example.com/ -> https://alice.example.com/somethingElse
+	NonCanonicalId = 1 << 0,
+	// Allow the final object to be at most one subdomain deeper than the request URL, similar to SPF relaxed alignment
+	//
+	// Currently no code path allows this flag to be set, but is kept in case of future use as some niche deployments do this, and we provide a pre-reviewed mechanism to opt-in.
+	//
+	// Allow variations:
+	//   good example: https://example.com/@user -> https://activitypub.example.com/@user { id: 'https://activitypub.example.com/@user' }
+	//   problematic example: https://example.com/@user -> https://untrusted.example.com/@user { id: 'https://untrusted.example.com/@user' }
+	MisalignedOrigin = 1 << 1,
+	// The requested URL has a different host than the returned object ID, although the final URL is still consistent with the object ID
+	//
+	// This condition is common for user-initiated lookups using an intermediate host but should not be allowed in federation loops
+	//
+	// Allow variations:
+	//   good example: https://alice.example.com/@user@bob.example.com -> https://bob.example.com/@user { id: 'https://bob.example.com/@user' }
+	//   problematic example: https://alice.example.com/definitelyAlice -> https://bob.example.com/@somebodyElse { id: 'https://bob.example.com/@somebodyElse' }
+	CrossOrigin = 1 << 2 | MisalignedOrigin,
+	// Allow all softfail flags
+	//
+	// do not use this flag on released code
+	Any = ~0
+}
 
-	const idOk = activity.id !== undefined && hosts.includes(new URL(activity.id).host);
+/**
+ * Fuzz match on whether the candidate host has authority over the request host
+ * 
+ * @param requestHost The host of the requested resources
+ * @param candidateHost The host of final response
+ * @returns Whether the candidate host has authority over the request host, or if a soft fail is required for a match
+ */
+function hostFuzzyMatch(requestHost: string, candidateHost: string): FetchAllowSoftFailMask {
+	const requestFqdn = requestHost.endsWith('.') ? requestHost : `${requestHost}.`;
+	const candidateFqdn = candidateHost.endsWith('.') ? candidateHost : `${candidateHost}.`;
 
-	// technically `activity.url` could be an `ApObject = IObject |
+	if (requestFqdn === candidateFqdn) {
-	// string | (IObject | string)[]`, but if it's a complicated thing
+		return FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict;
-	// and the `activity.id` doesn't match, I think we're fine
+	}
-	// rejecting the activity
-	const urlOk = typeof(activity.url) === 'string' && hosts.includes(new URL(activity.url).host);
 
-	if (!idOk && !urlOk) {
+	// allow only one case where candidateHost is a first-level subdomain of requestHost
-		throw new Error(`bad Activity: neither id(${activity?.id}) nor url(${activity?.url}) match location(${urls})`);
+	const requestDnsDepth = requestFqdn.split('.').length;
+	const candidateDnsDepth = candidateFqdn.split('.').length;
+
+	if ((candidateDnsDepth - requestDnsDepth) !== 1) {
+		return FetchAllowSoftFailMask.CrossOrigin;
+	}
+
+	if (`.${candidateHost}`.endsWith(`.${requestHost}`)) {
+		return FetchAllowSoftFailMask.MisalignedOrigin;
+	}
+
+	return FetchAllowSoftFailMask.CrossOrigin;
+}
+
+// normalize host names by removing www. prefix
+function normalizeSynonymousSubdomain(url: URL | string): URL {
+	const urlParsed = url instanceof URL ? url : new URL(url);
+	const host = urlParsed.host;
+	const normalizedHost = host.replace(/^www\./, '');
+	return new URL(urlParsed.toString().replace(host, normalizedHost));
+}
+
+export function assertActivityMatchesUrls(requestUrl: string | URL, activity: IObject, candidateUrls: (string | URL)[], allowSoftfail: FetchAllowSoftFailMask): FetchAllowSoftFailMask {
+	// must have a unique identifier to verify authority
+	if (!activity.id) {
+		throw new Error(`bad Activity: missing id field`);
+	}
+
+	let softfail = 0;
+
+	// if the flag is allowed, set the flag on return otherwise throw
+	const requireSoftfail = (needed: FetchAllowSoftFailMask, message: string) => {
+		if ((allowSoftfail & needed) !== needed) {
+			throw new Error(message);
+		}
+
+		softfail |= needed;
+	}
+
+	const requestUrlParsed = normalizeSynonymousSubdomain(requestUrl);
+	const idParsed = normalizeSynonymousSubdomain(activity.id);
+	
+	const candidateUrlsParsed = candidateUrls.map(it => normalizeSynonymousSubdomain(it));
+
+	const requestUrlSecure = requestUrlParsed.protocol === 'https:';
+	const finalUrlSecure = candidateUrlsParsed.every(it => it.protocol === 'https:');
+	if (requestUrlSecure && !finalUrlSecure) {
+		throw new Error(`bad Activity: id(${activity?.id}) is not allowed to have http:// in the url`);
+	}
+
+	// Compare final URL to the ID
+	if (!candidateUrlsParsed.some(it => it.href === idParsed.href)) {
+		requireSoftfail(FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId, `bad Activity: id(${activity?.id}) does not match response url(${candidateUrlsParsed.map(it => it.toString())})`);
+
+		// at lease host need to match exactly (ActivityPub requirement) 
+		if (!candidateUrlsParsed.some(it => idParsed.host === it.host)) {
+			throw new Error(`bad Activity: id(${activity?.id}) does not match response host(${candidateUrlsParsed.map(it => it.host)})`);
 		}
 	}
+
+	// Compare request URL to the ID
+	if (!requestUrlParsed.href.includes(idParsed.href)) {
+		requireSoftfail(FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId, `bad Activity: id(${activity?.id}) does not match request url(${requestUrlParsed.toString()})`);
+
+		// if cross-origin lookup is allowed, we can accept some variation between the original request URL to the final object ID (but not between the final URL and the object ID)
+		const hostResult = hostFuzzyMatch(requestUrlParsed.host, idParsed.host);
+
+		requireSoftfail(hostResult, `bad Activity: id(${activity?.id}) is valid but is not the same origin as request url(${requestUrlParsed.toString()})`);
+	}
+	
+	return softfail;
+}

packages/backend/src/server/ServerService.ts

@@ -103,6 +103,43 @@ export class ServerService implements OnApplicationShutdown {
 			serve: false,
 		});
 
+		// if the requester looks like to be performing an ActivityPub object lookup, reject all external redirects
+		//
+		// this will break lookup that involve copying a URL from a third-party server, like trying to lookup http://charlie.example.com/@alice@alice.com
+		//
+		// this is not required by standard but protect us from peers that did not validate final URL.
+		if (this.config.disallowExternalApRedirect) {
+			const maybeApLookupRegex = /application\/activity\+json|application\/ld\+json.+activitystreams/i;
+			fastify.addHook('onSend', (request, reply, _, done) => {
+				const location = reply.getHeader('location');
+				if (reply.statusCode < 300 || reply.statusCode >= 400 || typeof location !== 'string') {
+					done();
+					return;
+				}
+
+				if (!maybeApLookupRegex.test(request.headers.accept ?? '')) {
+					done();
+					return;
+				}
+
+				const effectiveLocation = process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production' ? location : location.replace(/^http:\/\//, 'https://');
+				if (effectiveLocation.startsWith(`https://${this.config.host}/`)) {
+					done();
+					return;
+				}
+
+				reply.status(406);
+				reply.removeHeader('location');
+				reply.header('content-type', 'text/plain; charset=utf-8');
+				reply.header('link', `<${encodeURI(location)}>; rel="canonical"`);
+				done(null, [
+					"Refusing to relay remote ActivityPub object lookup.",
+					"",
+					`Please remove 'application/activity+json' and 'application/ld+json' from the Accept header or fetch using the authoritative URL at ${location}.`,
+				].join('\n'));
+			});
+		}
+
 		fastify.register(this.apiServerService.createServer, { prefix: '/api' });
 		fastify.register(this.openApiServerService.createServer);
 		fastify.register(this.fileServerService.createServer);

packages/backend/src/server/api/endpoints/ap/show.ts

@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ import { UtilityService } from '@/core/UtilityService.js';
 import { bindThis } from '@/decorators.js';
 import { ApiError } from '../../error.js';
 import { IdentifiableError } from '@/misc/identifiable-error.js';
+import { FetchAllowSoftFailMask } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
 
 export const meta = {
 	tags: ['federation'],
@@ -53,11 +54,6 @@ export const meta = {
 			code: 'RESPONSE_INVALID',
 			id: '70193c39-54f3-4813-82f0-70a680f7495b',
 		},
-		responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch: {
-			message: 'Requested URI and response URI host does not match.',
-			code: 'RESPONSE_INVALID_ID_HOST_NOT_MATCH',
-			id: 'a2c9c61a-cb72-43ab-a964-3ca5fddb410a',
-		},
 		noSuchObject: {
 			message: 'No such object.',
 			code: 'NO_SUCH_OBJECT',
@@ -153,7 +149,8 @@ export default class extends Endpoint<typeof meta, typeof paramDef> { // eslint-
 
 		// リモートから一旦オブジェクトフェッチ
 		const resolver = this.apResolverService.createResolver();
-		const object = await resolver.resolve(uri).catch((err) => {
+		// allow ap/show exclusively to lookup URLs that are cross-origin or non-canonical (like https://alice.example.com/@bob@bob.example.com -> https://bob.example.com/@bob)
+		const object = await resolver.resolve(uri, FetchAllowSoftFailMask.CrossOrigin | FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId).catch((err) => {
 			if (err instanceof IdentifiableError) {
 				switch (err.id) {
 					// resolve
@@ -165,10 +162,7 @@ export default class extends Endpoint<typeof meta, typeof paramDef> { // eslint-
 					case '09d79f9e-64f1-4316-9cfa-e75c4d091574':
 						throw new ApiError(meta.errors.federationNotAllowed);
 					case '72180409-793c-4973-868e-5a118eb5519b':
-					case 'ad2dc287-75c1-44c4-839d-3d2e64576675':
 						throw new ApiError(meta.errors.responseInvalid);
-					case 'fd93c2fa-69a8-440f-880b-bf178e0ec877':
-						throw new ApiError(meta.errors.responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch);
 
 					// resolveLocal
 					case '02b40cd0-fa92-4b0c-acc9-fb2ada952ab8':

packages/backend/test/unit/ap-request.ts

@@ -8,6 +8,8 @@ import httpSignature from '@peertube/http-signature';
 
 import { genRsaKeyPair } from '@/misc/gen-key-pair.js';
 import { ApRequestCreator } from '@/core/activitypub/ApRequestService.js';
+import { assertActivityMatchesUrls, FetchAllowSoftFailMask } from '@/core/activitypub/misc/check-against-url.js';
+import { IObject } from '@/core/activitypub/type.js';
 
 export const buildParsedSignature = (signingString: string, signature: string, algorithm: string) => {
 	return {
@@ -24,6 +26,10 @@ export const buildParsedSignature = (signingString: string, signature: string, a
 	};
 };
 
+function cartesianProduct<T, U>(a: T[], b: U[]): [T, U][] {
+	return a.flatMap(a => b.map(b => [a, b] as [T, U]));
+}
+
 describe('ap-request', () => {
 	test('createSignedPost with verify', async () => {
 		const keypair = await genRsaKeyPair();
@@ -58,4 +64,123 @@ describe('ap-request', () => {
 		const result = httpSignature.verifySignature(parsed, keypair.publicKey);
 		assert.deepStrictEqual(result, true);
 	});
+
+	test('rejects non matching domain', () => {
+		assert.doesNotThrow(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://alice.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+		), 'validation should pass base case');
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://bob.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Any,
+		), 'validation should fail no matter what if the response URL is inconsistent with the object ID');
+		
+		// fix issues like threads
+		// https://github.com/misskey-dev/misskey/issues/15039
+		const withOrWithoutWWW = [
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			'https://www.alice.example.com/abc',
+		];
+
+		cartesianProduct(
+			cartesianProduct(
+				withOrWithoutWWW,
+				withOrWithoutWWW,
+			),
+			withOrWithoutWWW,
+		).forEach(([[a, b], c]) => {
+			assert.doesNotThrow(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+				a,
+				{ id: b } as IObject,
+				[
+					c,
+				],
+				FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+			), 'validation should pass with or without www. subdomain');
+		});
+	});
+
+	test('cross origin lookup', () => {
+		assert.doesNotThrow(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://bob.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://bob.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.CrossOrigin | FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId,
+		), 'validation should pass if the response is otherwise consistent and cross-origin is allowed');
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://bob.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://bob.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+		), 'validation should fail if the response is otherwise consistent and cross-origin is not allowed');
+	});
+
+	test('rejects non-canonical ID', () => {
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/@alice',
+			{ id: 'https://alice.example.com/users/alice' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://alice.example.com/users/alice'
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+		), 'throws if the response ID did not exactly match the expected ID');
+		assert.doesNotThrow(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/@alice',
+			{ id: 'https://alice.example.com/users/alice' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://alice.example.com/users/alice',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId,
+		), 'does not throw if non-canonical ID is allowed');
+	});
+
+	test('origin relaxed alignment', () => {
+		assert.doesNotThrow(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://ap.alice.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://ap.alice.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.MisalignedOrigin | FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId,
+		), 'validation should pass if response is a subdomain of the expected origin');
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.multi-tenant.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://alice.multi-tenant.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://bob.multi-tenant.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.MisalignedOrigin | FetchAllowSoftFailMask.NonCanonicalId,
+		), 'validation should fail if response is a disjoint domain of the expected origin');
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://ap.alice.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'https://ap.alice.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+		), 'throws if relaxed origin is forbidden');
+	});
+
+	test('resist HTTP downgrade', () => {
+		assert.throws(() => assertActivityMatchesUrls(
+			'https://alice.example.com/abc',
+			{ id: 'https://alice.example.com/abc' } as IObject,
+			[
+				'http://alice.example.com/abc',
+			],
+			FetchAllowSoftFailMask.Strict,
+		), 'throws if HTTP downgrade is detected');
+	});
 });

packages/frontend/src/scripts/lookup.ts

@@ -54,10 +54,6 @@ export async function lookup(router?: Router) {
 					title = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._responseInvalid.title;
 					text = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._responseInvalid.description;
 					break;
-				case 'a2c9c61a-cb72-43ab-a964-3ca5fddb410a':
-					title = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._responseInvalid.title;
-					text = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._responseInvalidIdHostNotMatch.description;
-					break;
 				case 'dc94d745-1262-4e63-a17d-fecaa57efc82':
 					title = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._noSuchObject.title;
 					text = i18n.ts._remoteLookupErrors._noSuchObject.description;